MacPhail's Collection Orkney Single Malt / Old Pulteney / Crown Royal

MacPhail's Collection Orkney Single Malt


Location of Distillery: Orkney, Scotland

Price: $89.00 (750ml)

Will's Review

• Overall rating: 7
• Smokiness: 6
• Sweetness: 5
• Quite decent. Like a child colouring in their notebook and trying to stay between the lines. They will inevitably mess it up but we tell them it's good anyway.

Old Pulteney


Location of Distillery: Wick, Scotland

Price: $89.65 (750ml)

Steve's Review

• Overall rating:
• Smokiness:
• Sweetness:

Max's Review

• Overall Rating: 6
• Smokiness: 3
• Sweetness: 4
• Very meh, run-of-the-mill sort of scotch, nothing really standards out. That being said, still an easy drinking scotch that's got good hints of vanilla and amber, slight hue of chocolate on the nose, and has a warm almost fiery sensation

Crown Royal Deluxe

 

















Location of Distillery: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Price: $41.95 (1140ml)

Matt's Review

• Overall Rating: 8
• Smokiness: 0
• Sweetness: 5
• Fruity tastes on top of a woody body with hints of honey. Nothing fancy, but an old easy drinking staple that gets the job done

Random Category - What image best describes this scotch?


Will -

Steve -

Max -

Matt -

A New Era

As our fellow scotch drinkers have moved to distant lands, we will be changing the format in how we present our prestigious ratings for the liquid amber we all cherish so dearly.

Since it will be difficult for us all to be drinking the same scotch at each meeting, we will each rate the scotch we have had that night. This will be a huge paradigm shift, but I think our fan base will understand.

Cheers,

Three Guys Three Cups